ChurnNote vs Stunning
Stunning is a mature failed-payment-recovery specialist on Stripe with deep multi-channel dunning (email, SMS, in-app), priced by MRR. ChurnNote ships failed payment recovery as one of six loops AND covers Smart Cancel Flow, Reply Intelligence, and Product-change win-backs at flat $12/mo on Stripe and Lemon Squeezy. Pick Stunning if dunning depth is the single most important thing. Pick ChurnNote if you want the whole lifecycle at one flat price.
ChurnNote
Personal exit emails, automated
Price: $12/mo or $99/year
Best for: Indie SaaS founders ($500-$15K MRR)
Focus: Post-cancellation feedback via personal emails
Stunning
Failed payment recovery specialist
Price: Flat fee scaling with MRR (~$120/mo at $40K MRR). 15-day trial
Best for: Stripe / Foxy / Subbly SaaS at scale where every recovered failed payment is worth $$$ and the deepest multi-channel dunning instrument matters most
Feature Comparison
| Feature | ChurnNote | Stunning |
|---|---|---|
| Stripe support | ✓ | ✓ |
| Lemon Squeezy support | ✓ | — |
| Foxy / Subbly support | — | ✓ |
| Failed payment recovery | Email, 3-step | Email + SMS + in-app, deep retry logic |
| Pre-dunning / upcoming-charge alerts | — | ✓ |
| Smart Cancel Flow (hosted save page) | ✓ | — |
| Churn Radar (at-risk signals) | ✓ | Partial via dunning dashboard |
| Reply Intelligence (structured) | Reason, sub-reason, recoverability, draft reply | — |
| Requests page (clusters asks) | ✓ | — |
| Product-change win-backs | ✓ | — |
| Recovered MRR per shipped change | ✓ | — |
| Multi-business (multiple accounts) | ✓ | — |
| Pricing | $12/mo flat, unlimited | Scales with MRR |
| Setup time | 60 seconds | Moderate |
Stunning Strengths
- ✓Battle-tested dunning with years of retry-logic tuning
- ✓Multi-channel outreach: email, SMS, in-app. ChurnNote is email-only here
- ✓Pre-dunning alerts and upcoming-charge notifications
- ✓Payment-update pages with backup payment method support
- ✓Detailed recovery dashboard with deep reporting
Where Stunning Falls Short
- ✗Dunning-only. No cancel flow, no Reply Intelligence, no Product-change win-backs
- ✗Pricing scales with MRR. At larger scale, the bill grows significantly
- ✗No Lemon Squeezy support
- ✗Nothing for voluntary cancellations. If a customer clicks cancel deliberately, Stunning doesn't see it
Dunning depth vs lifecycle breadth
This is the core trade-off. Stunning is a specialist that goes deep on a single loop. Their dunning instrument has years of retry-logic tuning, multi-channel outreach (SMS and in-app on top of email), and pre-dunning alerts that ChurnNote doesn’t match. If failed payments are your single biggest leak and you’re at the scale where SMS recovery moves real dollars, Stunning is the better instrument for that one job.
ChurnNote ships failed payment recovery as one of six loops. The dunning is email-only, on a 3-step Stripe-aware schedule. Functional, founder-grade, sent from your own domain. But not as deep as Stunning’s. The trade-off you’re making is: cover one loop deeply, or cover six loops at a flat price.
Where ChurnNote pulls ahead
Five lifecycle pieces Stunning doesn’t cover at all:
- Smart Cancel Flow.When a customer clicks cancel, ChurnNote shows the right save offer for their reason. Stunning doesn’t see this moment.
- Churn Radar.Forward-looking signals: scheduled cancels, abandoned cancel flow, inactive customers. Stunning’s radar is failed-payment focused only.
- Reply Intelligence. Every cancellation reply and cancel-flow feedback gets structured into reason, sub-reason, named feature or competitor, recoverability score, and a draft founder reply.
- Requests page.Clusters customer asks across cancellations into a roadmap. “API access, 5 customers asked.”
- Product-change win-backs. Record a ship, ChurnNote drafts targeted win-backs to the customers who asked for it and credits recovered MRR back to that specific change.
The pricing difference
Stunning’s flat fee scales with MRR (around $120/mo at $40K MRR). Flat $12 per month. No tiers, no per-event fees, no feature gating. For sub-$50K-MRR SaaS, the gap is large, and ChurnNote covers more of the lifecycle.
When to choose Stunning
You bill on Stripe, Foxy, or Subbly. Failed payments are your biggest churn lane. You’re at a scale where SMS and in-app dunning recover real dollars over email-only. You’re comfortable paying by MRR and don’t need the rest of the retention lifecycle.
When to choose ChurnNote
You bill on Lemon Squeezy and need an integration that exists. Or you bill on Stripe and want the whole retention lifecycle (Smart Cancel Flow, Reply Intelligence, Product-change win-backs, plus email-based failed payment recovery) at one flat price.
Related
See the broader best Stripe dunning tools roundup, or the Stunning alternative guide for the full list.
Try ChurnNote. $12/mo, cancel anytime
Connect Stripe or Lemon Squeezy. When a customer cancels, they get a personal email. You get their honest answer.
Get started with ChurnNote